My reasons for not liking the SuperKicks are very valid. They heads don't allow you to actually tune the drum. Because of the foam glued to the plastic material the head cannot vibrate across the frquency spectrum. Therefore you cannot get all the tonal possibilities the drum is capable of. This also causes an "unnatural" beater rebound.
As your abilities to tune get better you will start to realize the negative side of these particular heads. It's not that they are per say a bad product but they exploit a poor skilllset in tuning capabilities in drummers and soundtechs. The same folk whom like these heads are the same ones whom choke the drums out with huge pillows (some muffling is sometimes needed in a drum but some folk get ridiculous) and tape on every drum or have heads as loose and saggy as a hamuk (sp?).
i think audio was just playing not really being disrespectful or actually insulting you-- but that is just how i saw it
any way\
i disagree:
i hate a bunch of stuff in a bass drum on a gig..... the only time i do that is at home when i need to muffle the drum a lot....my drums sing- all of them- you heard my toms... even the bass drum will give me a 1-2 second resonance if i let the beater bounce off of the head.... so you are right it is all about tuning.......and i do know how...................
i would agree that i can't use the superkick to make my bass drum sound like just a bigger tom- but that is not what i want= the BOOM is what i have always wanted from my base drum ever since i was young- i would hear bass drums and always want something different... i never got it until i tried the superkick about 5 years ago or so.
i HATE slap on a bass drum.. and always have even before i knew anything about tuning or heads as a kid.... i don't know........ it's just what i like
and the thing is- most places i play, people comment on how they love the sound of my bass drum........... it just sounds good and hits hard and gives good bottom whether you hit it hard or soft.................
that is my case for the SK2