Ok...
I've followed this thread from the begining, just kinda taking things in...
I guess I'll add my 2 Abe Lincolns.
I respect Gerald and his contributions to the Craft, but to say that his conributions to the overall landscape of drumming are Gadd-like, Vinnie-esque, or Weckl-minded is a bit of a reach. I say that because Gerald's stuff is applicable to a small sector of the overall musical landscape. The stuff that Vinnie and Dave did/do translates across genere lines. Yes, I was relatively young when Gerald was in his prime, conversely I was probably barely alive (if at all) when Dave and Vinnie were hot in the 80's. I KNOW I wasn't around when Gadd burst on the scene in the 70's. I 100% respect what he brings to the table, honestly his stuff is a little dated. In the "what have you done for me lately?" world that we live in, it is tough to deal with a cat that one must dig back 20 years to find the best offerings of a particular player. I do not, however, think that it is disrespectful of cats to ask the question of why for it is simply a question.
I hope we can finally put our sticks down and quit hitting this dead horse.