Well if thats the way his Pastor wants it, I dont see what the problem is.
BTW, I love my overdriven leslie 
Not that there's a problem, but I just wouldn't play there.
That's my form of worship, and if I can't do it the way I feel I'm supposed to do it, then I'm not giving my all, and I might as well not be doing it.
That's just me, though.
As said above, I'm not talking chunkity-chunk palm muting madness, but my amp never leaves the lead channel. It's jut manipulated by my volume, touch, and pedals.
The overdriven leslie comment was a statement about hypocrisy. I'm sure that pastor loves him some Leslie, but that's not how the organ was designed, so it "shouldn't" be allowed, if overdrive isn't allowed--as that's not how the guitar was designed.
No offense to your pastor, Rown, but it's borderline cavemen-style-legalism, and I just can't get down with it.
I'd hate to imagine what's being missed if people aren't allowed to worship they was they are called to (note that I said "called" not "wave around a ribbon-tasseled tambourine randomly--but I guess that's between those people and God...)
Maybe I'm going overboard, but I know that I just can't play the same unless I've got MY stuff, and I'm "allowed" to use it--and if you can't play the way you're used to, then it's bad, and if it's bad, it's a distraction to those around you, and you're not putting worth for Him what you came to put forth. On top of that, you're taking away from those around you--which means you are taking away from God.
Actually, in any church I've played in, I didn't event ask that question. I just played. I've never had a complaint.
Not starting fights. I'm sorry. That just irks me to no end.