GTRDave to their defense in 5 - 4- 3 - 2 -
For today's matinee performance, the role of GTRDave will be played by MalthumbMore fallout from the Toyota mess.
1) There will be more recalls
2) The general public will (understandably) mis-interpret the meaning and intent of recalls
Automotive recalls happen A LOT and most of them are voluntary and not publically discussed. Maybe a 5 second blurb at 11:17 of the 11:00 news.
Typically a recall happens when a manufacturer either notices a statistical anamoly in their manufacturing process or in warranty occurences in the field. For example, a manufacturer might notice that the supplier of a wiring harness delivered a batch that has a statiscally significant increase of harnesses that exhibit a minor voltage spike. The manufacturer may decide to identify the total popluation that might be impacted and they might opt to recall them. If they choose to voluntarily recall them, they need to communicate to NHTSA what the concern is and what the POTENTIAL failure modes could be. It doesn't mean that it ever happened. It doesn't mean that every vehicle is LIKELY to exhibit the problem. I've been involved in recalls where we could statiscally show that there MIGHT be up to 16 vehicles built with a suspect part. Problem is, those 16 parts could have been in any of about 30,000+ vehicles built. Wells, since it was safety related, we recalled all 30,000 vehicles in order to check for the part. We knew what date stamps to look for on the supplier's parts, so the 29,984 vehicles that did not have a problem could be ruled out by a 5 minute inspection at the dealer.
The difference between the Chrysler situation and the Toyota situation is that Toyota did not do the pre-emptive type of voluntary recalls. They only reacted AFTER things had already gone to heck. And even then they had to be forced by NHTSA to do anything. Most recalls are about something that has a statistical possibility of happening. The Toyota recalls are about triage. Befre we dump Chrysler in the same basket with Toyota, let's wait to see if there have been any occurences in customer vehicles that led to the recall.