LearnGospelMusic.com Community

Main => Gospel Music Lounge => Topic started by: B_XALTED on April 20, 2010, 02:48:15 PM

Title: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B_XALTED on April 20, 2010, 02:48:15 PM
Do you get involved when you hear a domestic situation taking place? What is the first thought that you have? Just wondering. This is following a crazy incident that happened at my apartment complex the other night.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: under13 on April 20, 2010, 02:50:10 PM
I mind my business. I dont wanna get beat up too. :D

Really, the only thing I would do would be to call the police. :-\
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B_XALTED on April 20, 2010, 02:57:31 PM
I mind my business. I dont wanna get beat up too. :D

Really, the only thing I would do would be to call the police. :-\

Friday, I woke up to my neighbor screaming someone help me!!! I got up and looked in my peep hole, and her door was opened, and all I could hear was her husband muttering some erratic kind of language. She screamed again for someone to help her, and then she yelled at him "THATS YOUR DAUGHTER STOP!!! SOMEBODY HELP ME!!!"

I go to call 911, and while I am dialing, she beats at my door. I can hear him getting more aggressive. I look out the peep hole, and she is in the hall way screaming for help with her 1 year old in her hand. I open my door and she begs me to take her baby.

Not knowing the situation, I thought quickly and grabbed my cell, wallet and keys, and took her baby and went to get in my car. The police were showing up by then. The thing was he had some kind of breakdown, and attacked and choked his 5 year old. I dont know all the details, but I do know that there was a gun in the house as well.


I understand that people want to mind their own, but sometimes I think that we need to step out on that faith that we claim to have, and when we see another brother or sister in Christ in trouble like that, we need to try and help. i am not saying to be stupid at all... But think of this, I am surrounded by other apartments, and ALL are MEN. No one else ca,e out of their house. They didnt know what she was screaming for...

The fact that I live across the hall from her, played a major role. Someone called the police, it wasnt me or her. He broke her phone when she tried to call. When I called the call had already been made. So someone felt that their good deed for the day was that they called and that was it. Withouut knowing what else was going on.

I just couldnt bare to imagine if I didnt take her young daughter for her while she tried to get her husband under control. o have never seen what people mean by "demon possessed" but I saw it that morning. Its scary, but I know that it was nothing but God in that situation, because all of the "What if's..." that could have been a factor were not factors at all. 
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: under13 on April 20, 2010, 03:01:09 PM
If she knocked on my door, then I would let her in, but thats it. I'm not confronting a crazy dude with a gun. btjm. *shrug*
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B_XALTED on April 20, 2010, 03:02:52 PM
If she knocked on my door, then I would let her in, but thats it. I'm not confronting a crazy dude with a gun. btjm. *shrug*

I dont think I said I confronted anyone. But that was the situation... I said dont be stupid about it. That would be stupid, unless you had some heat too.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: JustBritt on April 20, 2010, 03:09:26 PM
One of my roomates was ggoing through that. That's a rough situation to deal with especially when it's happening right in front of you. Me and my other roomates  really didnt know what to do. She didnt want us to tell because he would have went to jail because her mom put out a restraining order against him. And he was on probation. Annyways if we did tell, we were gonna be kicked out the program. Cause we werent allowed to let outside people stay over and he was smoking weed. We did eventually say something to her though.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: lordluvr on April 20, 2010, 03:26:49 PM
I have, and I'll do it again in a heartbeat if it means I can help a defenseless woman or child keep from being harmed physically and emotionally.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B3Wannabe on April 20, 2010, 03:37:20 PM
WWJD?

This is another one of those things that I feel strongly about. We claim to have the power of the Almighty God behind us, but when there are injustices around us, we cower. In this case, the person is screaming for help, to not help them is wrong. Jesus said that himself. When she is crying for help, that's just like Jesus himself saying come help me. You might as well just deny Christ, because when it's your turn, he'll look at you and say, Who are you? BTJM.

With that said, I know that I don't want anything to happen to me or my family, but I have to believe that if I'm doing the right thing, he'll protect me. Fear is the enemy here.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: cordney on April 20, 2010, 03:46:22 PM
About 6yrs ago, my friend decided to intervene when a female was getting beat badly by some guy in the club.  He pulls the guy off of the female, only to have that dude friends surround him.  I seperated him and the group of guys...we decided to leave, when we walked outside the club...they were waiting and we got the brakes beat off of us.  It wasn't a pretty sight! 

He said, "I will never try to intervene again" and I concur.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: phbrown on April 20, 2010, 03:47:10 PM
I don't like to get involved because you never know the whole story. My basic guidelines is this.

If they are arguing but no actual physical violence is taking place then I just watch the situation.
If someone just gets hit once then I just continue to watch
If someone is clearly being stomped into the ground then I will call the police and intervene.
If someone yells fire or help or there is blood involved then I will call the police and intervene.


This remind me of what happened a few days ago....


Sunday afternoon I was on my way home and as I was driving the street I see a car with its trunk open and there is a man that appears to have his forearm across a woman's neck and it looks like he is pushing her into the trunk of the car. So stop in the middle of a busy road which is when they notice
me and both just start laughing and he lets her go. Then I continue on my way home.

I know it isn't not the same situation as the OP but yeah I will intervene.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: LaylaMonroe on April 20, 2010, 03:54:59 PM
I can't remember ever being in a position like that (if I was, I can't remember it right now as I type). But once when I first got to Detroit I was heading down Van Wyck one late night after work... it was probably about 10 or 11:00p. I noticed that the car in front of me kept swerving. When we got to a red light, I could see inside and noticed that the male driver was beating the crap out of his female passenger. I mean he was going for broke... beating her like she was a dude.  Then, the door opened and it appeared he was trying to push her out or something.  When the light turned green, he made a left, and I followed him dialing 9-1-1. At some point, he realized I was following him and he started driving really fast through some very residential streets, making all kinds of turns, in and out, down and around, toward dead ends and back roads. It was really dark and I would probably have been even MORE scared if I had stopped to think about it, but at the time, the only thing that scared me was my inability to drive that fast in an unfamiliar area. The operator kept asking me what direction I was going in, what neighborhood I was in, what street I was on and all that... and I couldn't answer any of her questions. She told me to pull over and stop following, but I told her I didn't see the police yet and I thought he was going to kill her.  Plus at that point, I was lost so without the police, I'd probably never find my way home. LOL

Anyway, I ended up losing him, never did see the police (if they ever even bothered to come), and I still find myself wondering about that lady to this day. I prayed intensely for her that night and for a long time thereafter. I believe she got out of that relationship because I remember when the burden to pray for her lightened up.

I would love to say that I would always help, but I'm not really positive. I think it depends on the circumstances and whether I have time to think.

WWJD?

This is another one of those things that I feel strongly about. We claim to have the power of the Almighty God behind us, but when there are injustices around us, we cower. In this case, the person is screaming for help, to not help them is wrong. Jesus said that himself. When she is crying for help, that's just like Jesus himself saying come help me. You might as well just deny Christ, because when it's your turn, he'll look at you and say, Who are you? BTJM.

With that said, I know that I don't want anything to happen to me or my family, but I have to believe that if I'm doing the right thing, he'll protect me. Fear is the enemy here.

Wow. I love the way you said that.


Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B3Wannabe on April 20, 2010, 04:31:59 PM
Wow. I love the way you said that.

Matt 25:31-46

Unless I'm reading it wrong....but anyway.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: LaylaMonroe on April 20, 2010, 04:35:48 PM
Matt 25:31-46

Unless I'm reading it wrong....but anyway.

Yeah, I knew exactly what scripture you were referring to because I wrote a one-pager on it for our Ordination Journal back in 08. I just like the way you said it.  ;D
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: nessalynn77 on April 20, 2010, 06:24:10 PM
The story that still bothers me to this day is the one about the young lady that was snatched from her house, leaving her young children alone.  The dude snatched her right off the porch, tied her up, and stuffed her in the back of his car.  The thing that gets me, is another driver saw her looking desperate and frantic through a back window and called 911.  The car turned and the driver didn't follow, I think they were instructed not to... the driver had the wrong color and make of the car, so the police were searching for the wrong vehicle during a time when time was so precious... they found her body the next day...

That tears me up, because if just one of those things that went wrong had gone right, she would've been at home with her kids instead of in the morgue.  I think the story said she got her hands on her cell and tried to make calls... can you imagine fighting so hard, and just missing getting rescued?  Crazy.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: LaylaMonroe on April 20, 2010, 09:28:41 PM
Dang Nessa, that story just tore me up. :'(

Ugh. So sad. So tragic.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: Fenix on April 21, 2010, 03:03:47 AM
If it is verbal violence, i stay well away. If it is physical stuff, i get involved.

My mom had to save our neighbor from his wife once. The woman had turned that dude into a blithering buffoon. Poor guy.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: Gibby on April 21, 2010, 07:00:02 AM
If it is verbal violence, i stay well away. If it is physical stuff, i get involved.

Well said.

Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: MissMusic04 on April 21, 2010, 07:14:02 AM
With just a man and woman, I will call 911 in a heartbeat. I've done it before. Definitely not stepping in and I won't let them see me on the phone. If he'll beat her, he'll beat me and I can't have that. I'll have to make some phone calls and have Uncle Joe and nem handle bizness.

If it's a man I know, I will intervene. I saw a really close friend of mine about to hit his girl cause he busted her cheating with his boy. Like she was BUSTED. CAUGHT, in the act. I was able to calm him down, though.

If there is a child near/involved, I will try my hardest to find a way to get them away, while calling 911.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: Fenix on April 21, 2010, 07:23:12 AM

I was able to calm him down, though.


Now how exactly did you do that? What did you say?
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: MissMusic04 on April 21, 2010, 07:35:38 AM
Now how exactly did you do that? What did you say?

It wasn't easy! He was like a full pot of boiling water! I had to talk fast. I told him she wasn't worth going to jail over. I started naming people who would be really hurt if he went to jail. His mother(he's her oldest son) his little brother, his little sister, his pastor. I said some other things too. He ended up just walking away, punching walls and kicking cars.  He was really hurt. He always gives 100% in a relationship. He was a flowers, candles, massage your feet kinda guy.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: Fenix on April 21, 2010, 07:48:36 AM
He was really hurt. He always gives 100% in a relationship. He was a flowers, candles, massage your feet kinda guy.

That <insert colloquial word used for a female dog> didn't deserve him.

Sorry LGM.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: Gibby on April 21, 2010, 07:54:54 AM
If it's a man I know, I will intervene. I saw a really close friend of mine about to hit his girl cause he busted her cheating with his boy. Like she was BUSTED. CAUGHT, in the act. I was able to calm him down, though.
It wasn't easy! He was like a full pot of boiling water! I had to talk fast. I told him she wasn't worth going to jail over. I started naming people who would be really hurt if he went to jail. His mother(he's her oldest son) his little brother, his little sister, his pastor. I said some other things too. He ended up just walking away, punching walls and kicking cars.  He was really hurt. He always gives 100% in a relationship. He was a flowers, candles, massage your feet kinda guy.

See stuff like that gets on my nerves.  Try to be a NICE GUY and this is what you get. I woulda let him get a few shots in...BTJM
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: MissMusic04 on April 21, 2010, 08:24:04 AM
That <insert colloquial word used for a female dog> didn't deserve him.

Sorry LGM.

She definitely did not. She tried calling him a few times. Apologizing, crying and all that.

See stuff like that gets on my nerves.  Try to be a NICE GUY and this is what you get. I woulda let him get a few shots in...BTJM

 :D :D :D, Shoot, I wanted to get a couple of jabs.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: sistagurl on April 21, 2010, 02:18:37 PM
I'd think like this..if it were my sister, my mother, or any loved one would I want someone to step in and help? Especially if that was all the help they may have????

I'd hope I could help in some way if I was needed. Now I agree when guns or weapons are involved, I'll call the poe poe. "Momma didn't raise no fool"! But I maaaay risk a beat down to help someone. Because I couldn't sat there and listen or watch someone getting beat down.

There was a situation once when I was about 7. I vagely remember it...but my sister and her husband were living with us. They got into an argument and she started screaming bloody murder...calling my dad (was her step). He broke in the door cause her husband had locked it. I don't know what went on in the room. There was a lot of bumping and tussling but my dad came out with a gun. I've never forgotten that. They had to leave after that, because my dad wouldn't let him stay and she wouldn't leave him. But he intervened even with a gun involved. I guess if it's your family some may risk that but for a stranger??....... :-\
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: LaylaMonroe on April 21, 2010, 02:49:07 PM
I'd think like this..if it were my sister, my mother, or any loved one would I want someone to step in and help? Especially if that was all the help they may have????

I'd hope I could help in some way if I was needed. Now I agree when guns or weapons are involved, I'll call the poe poe. "Momma didn't raise no fool"! But I maaaay risk a beat down to help someone. Because I couldn't sat there and listen or watch someone getting beat down.

There was a situation once when I was about 7. I vagely remember it...but my sister and her husband were living with us. They got into an argument and she started screaming bloody murder...calling my dad (was her step). He broke in the door cause her husband had locked it. I don't know what went on in the room. There was a lot of bumping and tussling but my dad came out with a gun. I've never forgotten that. They had to leave after that, because my dad wouldn't let him stay and she wouldn't leave him. But he intervened even with a gun involved. I guess if it's your family some may risk that but for a stranger??....... :-\


I will ask the question everyone will want to know: are they still together?

Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: Fenix on April 21, 2010, 02:53:56 PM
Yeah Sis'gurl, are they still together?
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B_XALTED on April 21, 2010, 02:57:48 PM
I didnt know that her husband had a gun or that a gun was involved until after the police were there taking statements. She then pointed them in the direction to where she threw it, and then she gave them the magazine for it.

I most definitely wouldnt have intervened if he was shooting, or if I knew that he had a gun. I look at it like this... Everywhere that she was standing in her house in that situation, of he would have shot at her, those bullets would have come through my living room, and bedroom.

I praise God that I was there for her, and that it did nto go as far as that, cause I have a bad knee and bad back... LOL. I cant run but so fast, and but so far... :D I talked to another neighbor yesterday, and she said that she didnt hear a thing. I was so shocked, seeing as how the ambulance, fire truck and police were parked in front of her deck... Crazy.

Well, she is morving out, and I no longer have to find a new place to live, for the moment. I still get scared at home, becuase now I live by myself, and I am almost paranoid. I am trying to shake this feeling. I think that this situation just showed me that we dont have control over ANYTHING on this earth, The outcome will always be God's decision... It was a wake up call. And having said that, I am not as afraid... cause I cant control a thing.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: sistagurl on April 21, 2010, 03:19:31 PM
Nope, they broke up not long after that. He moved up north and got with someone else.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: Cheetara23 on April 21, 2010, 04:17:01 PM
When I was little, my mother was attacked and almost raped by this man she barely knew. It was early evening and they were outside. The man came after her with a broken bottle and everything. My mom was screaming and begging for help...they were right near an apartment complex. A man heard my mom screaming and the man attacking her and he called out "Is everything ok out there?" The man said everything was fine, even though my mom was crying and begging for this man to call the police and help her. She said the man just said he don't want no trouble and went back in. If my mom hadn't fought so hard for her life she would've never gotten away from that man. She ran home and came in, blood all on her. So this is sort of a sensitive subject. If you don't want to physically involve yourself, at Least call the police.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B3Wannabe on April 21, 2010, 05:42:52 PM
When I was little, my mother was attacked and almost raped by this man she barely knew. It was early evening and they were outside. The man came after her with a broken bottle and everything. My mom was screaming and begging for help...they were right near an apartment complex. A man heard my mom screaming and the man attacking her and he called out "Is everything ok out there?" The man said everything was fine, even though my mom was crying and begging for this man to call the police and help her. She said the man just said he don't want no trouble and went back in. If my mom hadn't fought so hard for her life she would've never gotten away from that man. She ran home and came in, blood all on her. So this is sort of a sensitive subject. If you don't want to physically involve yourself, at Least call the police.

I had the same thing happen to me. He was in his late 20s. I was 12. He had a gun somewhere, but not on him. I had a bat and a dog.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: nessalynn77 on April 21, 2010, 06:36:45 PM
Wow.  Those last two posts put a whole different spin on it.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: JustBritt on April 21, 2010, 06:48:29 PM
Right. I was thinking the same thing Ness.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: SavnBass on April 22, 2010, 08:45:55 AM
If someone asks me for my help and I am ina position to render it I will do so. My life and every situation is in the hands of someone bigger than me or them..  It is tougher when you see or hear it from the outside.. but if I say for instance heard it I wold call the police... if I saw it I wold call the police... but if it was a situation like what you mentioned I would have no cho8ice but to help and let GOD.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: BassMan2000 on April 22, 2010, 12:33:10 PM
I would help with no hesitation.

There are many things I dislike, but abusing a woman or child really anger me.

In my military career I have stop many forms of abuse. The first time was when I was station in Hawaii.
This kid would just scream and cry. I would call the MP's but nothing would happen.  So one night when it happened I when to the house confronted both the parents and ended up fighting both of them.

The child aunt came to Hawaii to pick him up in the end.

I hand to take anger manager classes with the parents. The counselor asked what would it take to end the dislike and I replied "stop beating you kid".

I do carry a gun and well train to use it.

Going up I seem my Mother, Aunts abused. My sister was abused by her cousin years ago, but never said a word.  She later said she was afraid we would kill him.

And again I hate abuse, to do nothing is not an answer.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B3Wannabe on April 22, 2010, 05:47:31 PM
I would help with no hesitation.

There are many things I dislike, but abusing a woman or child really anger me.

In my military career I have stop many forms of abuse. The first time was when I was station in Hawaii.
This kid would just scream and cry. I would call the MP's but nothing would happen.  So one night when it happened I when to the house confronted both the parents and ended up fighting both of them.

The child aunt came to Hawaii to pick him up in the end.

I hand to take anger manager classes with the parents. The counselor asked what would it take to end the dislike and I replied "stop beating you kid".

I do carry a gun and well train to use it.

Going up I seem my Mother, Aunts abused. My sister was abused by her cousin years ago, but never said a word.  She later said she was afraid we would kill him.

And again I hate abuse, to do nothing is not an answer.


I sat and had a conversation with two of my neighbors for a couple hours Tuesday night. These dudes are KUN--TREE! They're so country, they still use the word "Colored". ;D ;D They were both drunk, but they both said that if they ever saw someone trying to break into our house, they would shoot them. They're the type that are always watching. And their front doors are almost always wide open, shotgun sitting right next to the door.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B_XALTED on April 22, 2010, 05:52:15 PM
I sat and had a conversation with two of my neighbors for a couple hours Tuesday night. These dudes are KUN--TREE! They're so country, they still use the word "Colored". ;D ;D They were both drunk, but they both said that if they ever saw someone trying to break into our house, they would shoot them. They're the type that are always watching. And their front doors are almost always wide open, shotgun sitting right next to the door.

Where is this at?
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B3Wannabe on April 22, 2010, 05:59:06 PM
Where is this at?

Laquey, MO - Town of about 900 people.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: B_XALTED on April 22, 2010, 06:51:11 PM
...just found out that my neighbors husband bonded out Tuesday... The justice system is really crazy. I mean, seriously, the site that I saw in no way would warrant this man being let go on bond.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: Banointed on April 23, 2010, 04:21:10 PM
Thank God for the person who called and thank God you were there for the child. the women needed help and I know I would have jumped in to help. children witnessing violence with parents is an awful thing. I pray they all get the help needed.
Title: Re: Domestic Violence... Do you help or not?
Post by: jcc4t on April 23, 2010, 04:51:36 PM
I only get involved if the woman is serious about getting out of that relationship because most of the time, these women and men wait until things die down and run right back into his or her arms because they can't see past their limitations. Say for instance you get involved and get seriously hurt where you are wheelchair bound and that couple is back together?  You got hurt for nothing. I'd just call the police and let somebody else who has the strenghth and gutts to stand up to a crazy people, and let them deal with it. While they're doing that, I'll be in a corner on the phone calling 911.