Now I can give an honest opinion. I really can't say that one sounds better than the other one. If you put new strings on both, the set both eqs flat, then I'll be able to say what sounds better to me. I can say that the schecter is holding more sustain to me. If I were you, I would probably use both basses, use the carvin for upbeat songs, and use the schecter for ballads and slower tempo songs. I'm currently looking at getting a Lakland, and if I get that, I'm going to put Barts in my schecter and tune it Eb Ab Db Gb B so that I can play ballads with it, and use the Lakland for slapping and upbeat tempo songs, tuned Bb Eb Ab Db Gb. That's my take.