I think alot of what is considered "traditional" or "contemporary" depends on perspective. For example, you have your "older" or "hardcore" traditional gospel like Mahalia Jackson, Clara Ward, The Caravans, James Cleveland, etc. Then you have older traditional choirs like Mattie Moss Clark's older releases with the Michigan State Choir. Then you have what is called "New Traditional", which is traditional gospel with a modern or contemporary flair, like some of Mississippi Mass Choir, Dottie Peoples, the late James Moore, Thomas Whitfield, Kurt Carr, Kirk Franklin (with the Family), if you listen to some of the chords, they are jazzy and contemporary, then you have contemporary gospel like The Clark Sisters, The Winans, Kim Burrell, Karen Clark, Smokie Norful, etc., and then there is the "Urban Contemporary" artists like Tonex, Tye Tribbett, Mary Mary, Kirk Franklin (W Gods Property and 1NC).
Then you have traditional gospel that includes other categories as well like "church" music (hymns, call and response songs, shout music, etc.) and "quartet music". You also have other contemprorary categories like "church" praise and worship songs (Martha Munizzi, Israel and New Breed), and then you have gospel reggae and holy hip-hop.
It all pretty much depends on your taste in music and what you grew up with! As a young person myself (sortof, I'm 28), I grew up with the church music in church (hymns, call/response, shout music) and with contemporary gospel of the 70s/80s like the Winans, Clark Sisters, Commissioned, Vanessa Bell, and with choirs such as the Tommies, the Southeast Inspirational Choir, and even with 70s soul/secular music. My taste in music is very broad. I love the simple message in the traditional songs and the music of the more contemporary songs.
I believe we cannot forget where we come from. I have an appreciation for older music like James Cleveland and Mahalia Jackson, but I cannot sit and listen to that kind of music for a long period of time because that is just not my favorite style of music. However I did listen ALOT to my old Caravans and Sam Cooke records (go figure!!) The traditional music I prefer is choirs and church music like hymns and call/response (since that is part of what I grew up with) But this just goes to show you that gospel has a wide range of styles, but I definitely have a soft spot for gospel that sounds "gospely" if u know what I mean. A lot of the newer music has lost the sincerity and anointing of the older music. The main thing for me is that your MESSAGE reflects Jesus Christ and that you don't water down your presentation to fit in with the world.
WOW!! This post ended up being much longer than I anticipated. Sorry!!!
Loopy