The best player argument is a hard one when judging a team sport. If this was track, golf or swimming it would be easier. In a team sport, the best player usually has to sacrifice individual statistics, usually shot attempts, to win. Consequently, I place more weight on championships won than statistics. Its very difficult to compare eras. For example, in Magic's era, the rules were, IMO, tougher and free agency was not as wild as it is now. If I had to choose, I would give Magic the slight edge over Kobe. However, in Kobe's defence, Magic played with two other hall of famers that were able to compliment his passing game. Kobe maybe the only hall of famer on his team.